COVID-19 Ventilation research and studies

COVID-19 Ventilation research and studies

The Ministry’s COVID-19 ventilation response and guidance has been informed by a number of international and local studies and research, to investigate and confirm the appropriate evidence-based strategy for the context of New Zealand classrooms.

 

Late in 2021 the Ministry set up the Ventilation Technical Advisory Group (VTAG), with ventilation experts from the Ministry of Health, Victoria University of Wellington, Canterbury University, Massey University, NIWA, BRANZ and GNS Science to provide the Ministry of Education with advice including support for the studies below.

Classroom ventilation study

Our study with NIWA, performed in consultation with VTAG, helped us understand more about classroom ventilation and verify our COVID-19 ventilation strategy for New Zealand schools.

The study involved looking at ventilation levels in typical classrooms being used as they normally are during the day. This was done by monitoring CO2 levels, which indicates how much fresh air flow there is, in 18 different classrooms across three schools.

The study verified that good ventilation can be achieved in most naturally ventilated classrooms by opening windows and doors. The study highlighted the added benefits of opening windows and doors on different sides of the room, of introducing short breaks to periodically purge the room of stale air, and of supplementary assisted natural ventilation systems (e.g. fixed extract/exhaust fans).

It also identified other areas for further research including classroom ventilation in cold weather, and the effective use of portable air cleaners and other supplementary measures.
 

Download
Download
NIWA rapid study
Download the results from our study with NIWA
Download the results from our study with NIWA

The Effectiveness of Natural Ventilation: A Case Study of a Typical New Zealand Classroom with Simulated Occupation

As a follow-on to the classroom ventilation study, this study assessed how the ventilation was impacted by different opening areas, differing indoor versus outdoor temperatures, and by supplementary measures such as portable air cleaners and fans.

Download
Download
Natural Ventilation
The Effectiveness of Natural Ventilation
The Effectiveness of Natural Ventilation

The Impact of Natural Ventilation During Winter on Thermal Comfort in Classrooms – A Systematic Literature Review

The aim of this literature review was to review the available literature on the impact of natural ventilation during winter on thermal comfort.

Download
Download
Ventilation in Winter
Impact of Natural Ventilation in Winter on Thermal Comfort
Impact of Natural Ventilation in Winter on Thermal Comfort

The Performance of Portable HEPA Air Cleaners in Naturally Ventilated Classrooms – A Systematic Literature Review

This literature review summarises the current (at time of writing) research on the performance of portable air cleaners used in naturally ventilated classrooms for the purpose of COVID-19 mitigation.

Download
Download
HEPA Air Cleaners
HEPA Air Cleaners in Naturally Ventilated Classrooms
HEPA Air Cleaners in Naturally Ventilated Classrooms

The Effectiveness of Preheating and Refresh Breaks in Classrooms

From May 2022 the ventilation programme initiated a temporary monitoring study through the winter season of CO2, temperature and humidity in 169 spaces at 43 schools nationwide.  This study analysed the data with a focus on investigating how preheating rooms and taking refresh breaks (i.e. deliberate opening of multiple doors and windows, preferably while vacating the room) impacted CO2 and temperature levels. 

The findings generally showed that for most of the monitored teaching time, the CO2 levels were largely less than 800 ppm (67% of the time) and were within the temperature range of 18-25 °C (70% of the time). While the indoor air temperatures were similar in all Climate Zones, CO2 levels were higher in colder climates. 

A warmer temperature when teaching started in the morning may have played a positive role in lowering CO2 levels throughout the day, and indoor air temperature drop was likely to be limited when breaks and refresh breaks occurred.

Download
Download
Preheating and Refresh Breaks
Effectiveness of Preheating and Refresh Breaks in Classrooms
Effectiveness of Preheating and Refresh Breaks in Classrooms

Evaluation of Ventilation in Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEs) Centres

In August 2022, the ventilation programme initiated a ventilation monitoring initiative which involved continuous monitoring of carbon dioxide (CO2), temperature and humidity levels in five ECEs spread across the country. This report is based on the data collected, which evaluated the ventilation performance of naturally ventilated ECEs to inform proactive ventilation management and improvement guidelines.

Download
Download
Ventilation in ECEs
Ventilation in Early Childhood Education and Care Centres
Ventilation in Early Childhood Education and Care Centres